Buck Hollow Sporting Goods - click or touch to visit their website Midwest Habitat Company

fixed blade or mechanicle broadheads?

Dbl.throat_patch

dbl.throat_patch
Hello all just wanted to say this is a wonderfull web sight you have here. I love to read the conversations between everyone. Here's my question, right now i hunt with 100 gr. thunderheads. I am thinking of trying mechanicles. I would love to here anyones feedback as to their preference and why.
 
cant help you on this one.i use zwickeys and see no reason to change
 
I hate to answer a question with a question but why are you considering switching? Are you having problems with the fixed blade? I've taken many animals with the fixed blade broadhead and as the old saying goes "Don't fix it if it aint broke"

Good luck
Pupster
 
I also use 100 gr. thunderheads and have for many years. I have no problems with them. But you never know until you try. I have many friends who use mechanicals and they work very well on whitetails. Excellent bloodtrails will come with either one as long as the shot placement is good. If you never try you will never know.
 
Welcome hawkeybucker,
I am kind of in the same boat as you however I love them on turkeys and am going to try them on deer this year. Good Luck and again, welcome.
 
I too heve friends who shoot mechanicals and they do love them. I'm on the coservative side if you can't tell so switching for me just wasn't the thing to do since the fixed has worked well for me. Here are a few of the pro's and con's I've heard from fellow bowhunters:

Pro's: They fly like a field point and you shouldn't have to adjust any sights. They have a larger cutting diameter once blades are deployed.

Cons: Small entry wound. Severe angle shots the blade won't expand simultaneously causing the arrow to kick thus losing penetration. Broadhead blade were often broke due to the hinged blade.
Remember these are just comments from friends of mine, not to a make judgement on mechanicals as a whole.

Mountain man makes a good point, You never know 'till you try, you might just love them.

Good Luck and also welcome
Pupster
 
Thanks for the feed back and i think you guys said it right if it aint broke don't fix it. I havn't had any bad luck with the thunderheads I was just wondering about new ideas. I will probally stick with the thunderheads. thanks all
 
Since were on the broadhead topic. I'll jump in with this. I have shot razorback 3's for the last few years but they have quit making them. (They have come out with a new version at 10 bucks a piece) Anyway I need to find a new fixed blade broadhead. I hear good things about thunderheads and never anything bad on Muzzys. So that is the direction I'm heading. Any experience's with these out there I would appreciate. Or if anyone has another good one let me know. I was perfectly happy with my old razorbacks but I've only got three left and one has been used pretty hard. Any info would be appreciated. Thanks
Frank
smile.gif
 
Razorbacks are made by New Archery Products the same company that makes thunderheads. If you like the way mechanicals fly and like the way fixed blades penetrate, try Steelforce broadheads. You will get the best of both. I've read where some people question their strength, but I just talked to a guy who used them in Africa and said they worked great on animals a lot bigger and tougher than whitetails. My only experience with them is a doe I shot last year. Good blood trail, but it was a 12 ring shot.
 
First of all let me say if your thunderheads fly the same as field points I'd consider staying with them.

I shot Thunderhead 125's for years and had great luck with them. The reason I went to mechanicals is that the Thunderheads didn't pattern the same as field points.

The only mechanicals I've really tried are Rocket steelheads. They group the same as my field points so I no longer have to do as much tuning with broadheads. I've also had great penetration with probably over 75% being complete pass throughs. I am quite picky about my shot selection so most shots are broadside or close to broadside and this has a lot to do with short blood trails. Many animals drop in sight and I don't think any of the last 20 or so have gone over 200 yards, most much less. This includes not only some mature whitetail but also kudu, gemsbuck and zebra.

I'm sure there are some other good mechanicals out there but I'd be causious about those with large cutting diameters.

Conclusion-I think there are some great fixed blade broadheads and some great mechanicals. I think there are some poor choices also.
 
I guess I look at it this way. Although we've all heard stories about how the buck shot with the mechanical head went down in three seconds and sprayed blood for twenty feet on either side of the gaping holes in his midsection, we mostly DON'T hear of the ones lost or wounded with these heads. I've seen mechanicals that were destroyed when they hit shoulder sockets of deer and failed to penetrate more than an inch or two. Ive also seen where the mechanical head, with it's large cutting diameter lodged in the opposite shoulder (shot was almost straight down) so very little blood and a lost deer. They are great, I think, if all your shots are perfectly broadside and there is NO chance of even a tiny twig in your way. Eventually, I think a mechanical will dissappoint, whereas a solid fixed blade or two blade would have performed. I shoot Magnus 4 blades, I think they're great but the Muzzy and Thunderheads are super too. Have fun.
 
I guess that I would beg to differ with some of the opinions on mechanical broadheads. I have shot 100 gr. spitfires for the last 4 years and have shot both deer and coyotes with them. I have taken a couple of the deer with shots that were quartering away and have not had any trouble with penetration or with the blades not opening. The arrow flight is extremely good, and the cutting diameter is very impressive. I shot Muzzy's previous to this and have nothing bad to say about them as I think they are also a good choice. I guess it boils down to whatever gives the hunter the most confidence to make a good shot and quick kill.

Good hunting to all!!!!
 
Hawkeyebucker, I posted this same question a few months ago. I was thinking about trying out mechanical broadheads too but I decided after some debate to stay with my 100 gr. Muzzy's for deer. I have never had a failure with them and they have always flown very good. When I saw your post it peeked my curiosity again but I still think I'll stick with my Muzzy's.
smile.gif
 
I have been using 100g Muzzys for years and I really like them. On the other hand I am heading to Wyoming to try for Pronghorn this year and wanted a little help with my 40 yard shot since I think I will have trouble getting them in as close as we get whitetails in. My Muzzys work great at 20 yards, but I could use some help at 40 so I am trying some Rocket mechanicals. For whitetails I am planning on sticking with 25 yard shots and closer so I think I'll stick with the Muzzys. I'll let you know what I think of the mechanicals after Wyoming.
 
I'm going through this decision again this year. Last year I stuck with my Thunderheads. This year I inherited my son's Hoyt overdraw and my arrow length went from 31" to 27". Plus, I drew my dream tag, Arizona archey bull unit 1. Been told to practice out to 50 yards. I added the pin and will practice, but only just in case. I am real curious to see if these new short arrows will get squirrely at the longer distance.
 
i can't begin to tell you guys how many customers i've talked to that have had bad experiences with mechanicals. i even had one myself and immediately went back to thunderhead 125s.i never would have evn tried them but a rep talked me into it. it ain't rocket sceince,just think about how much energy is absorbed when the head hits and the arms shoot out.many big game outfitters won't let their clients use them.one the best whitetail outfitters[and one of the best hunters] mark flickinger, won't allow his hunters to use them either.stick to the premium fixed blades[t-head ,muzzy,etc,] they are the best bone breakers and the most reliable. we owe it to the critters were hunting to provide a quick clean kill.
 
ZIM
Congratulations on the Arizona Bull tag!!! I am envious. If it's your first time there, you won't want to leave. I'm up to 6 bonus points since my last hunt there. Have been drawn 4 times since 1975 with some non-application years in between. Good luck!!!!
Thunderheads and heavy arrows for me.
Don
 
I had my bow setup perfect with big aluminum arrows and 125 grain Thunderheads. But I didn't like the bending some of them took to.

I switched to carbon arrows for more durability and had a planing motion with the thunderheads so I switched to Rocket Steelhead 125's.

They shoot a half inch lower or so than thunderheads at 20 yards.

Buddy of mine and his friend has taken an elk a year for 5 years with them, one was 54 yards and an antelope at 72 yards with steelheads.
 
One last thought, a heavier arrow and broadhead setup besides its robust characteristics and durability, helps control bow noise, big time.
 
Just got back from my 1st long range practice session with my new bow, shooting my new short Gold Tip XT's. Kept all my 6 arrow groups at 50 yards in 6" groups. Only now I get to put my broadheads on and see what happens. It usually ain't pretty.
 
Top Bottom