Buck Hollow Sporting Goods - click or touch to visit their website Midwest Habitat Company

My best and worst day ever, 10/27....

M

Monster Doe

Guest
Wednesday the 27th began as one of the best days of bowhunting I've ever had and ended the following morning in heartbreak.

After getting off work a bit early I decided to hunt a spot I've left untouched all season, and I had a good feeling about it while walking in the mist to my treestand. After fighting mosquitos for about an hour finally temps started to fall a bit and I settled in for what promised to be an action packed night. Sure enough, around 5 PM a large old doe meanders toward my location, stopping every few minutes to look behind her. I half expected a younger buck was back there harassing her, but was preparing myself mentally for other possibilities. Then he shows himself - and would you believe it, one of the largest bucks I've ever laid eyes on, a huge heavy and super tall typical that I'm guessing was right around that B&C class. I prepare myself but so far I can't tell which side of my stand they are going to go by. The doe turns, and proceeds to angle downwind of me!!! NOOOO! Boss hoss follows, my heart drops. Time to trust in The Ghost scent eliminator, that's what it's for, right? Well, the doe passed right by and didn't have a clue, at that point I knew I was safe and was probably going to get a shot. He follows and steps into my small shooting lane (never planned for or seen deer take this route, ever) and I grunt. He stops, perfect broadside at 30 yards.....I tensed my back muscles and the shot was away! PERFECT SHOT! At least that's what I thought until I heard CRACK! The sound of broadhead hitting a large bone structure, which I've decided after talking with friends had to have been some part of the shoulder. Thinking right now about where the shot hit and I don't understand how it could've hit forward enough to get shoulder, but it had to have. Later I found my broken off arrow ten feet from the scene of the crime, and only four inches including the broadhead were in the deer. I leave promptly to give the deer a few hours to bed down and die(in the case I did get a lung)and round up some friends. We found a decent blood trail and got an idea where he headed but decided against pursuing that night.

That night was agonizing, and in the morning my worst nightmare came true. We picked up the trail right away and found where he bedded. The bed was dry(it had rained all night)! All blood and other sign totally vanished, we scoured the area for six hours, nothing.

Since I started seriously bowhunting eleven years ago I've never shot a deer and not recovered it, I consider myself fortunate for that but also knew my time would come. What really turns my stomach is why did it have to be this deer? The deer of a lifetime for 98% of us? (Old Buck and OneCam are iowawhitetail.com's resident 2%ers) Not only that, my shot location was perfect, at least it looked like a perfect hit from the stand. I was so confident in the hit and so sure he was down within 75 yards, only to have my bowhunting world turned upside down.
frown.gif


I will continue to search for him, but from the looks of it he might live, and I hope he does. I hope I don't have to feel like this ever again, and feel horrible about myself when I practice so hard and know when I take a shot at a living creature, I owe it a quick and clean kill. Sorry about the rant, talking about it helps.....a little.
frown.gif
frown.gif
frown.gif
frown.gif
frown.gif
frown.gif
frown.gif
frown.gif
frown.gif
frown.gif
frown.gif
 
Hey DM,
Give it your best effort and search until you are satisfied. Usually it's just a matter of time before something like this happens. Try to keep your head up. I remember the last one I lost, I didn't even want to hunt anymore but was glad my mentors got me back in the stand.

Sorry to hear the news.

Pupster
 
Hang in there Rog.....he'll show up. Maybe if you rubbed Chris's head that would help.
 
I know how you feel. I did this same thing 5 years ago, and i still think about it
frown.gif
. That's why it's a challenging sport. Keep practicing and hunting hard and good things will
happen . I bet that buck will still be walking around a month from now.
waytogo.gif
 
Same happened to me 2 years ago. Was only 10 yards away. Right when I released he took a slight step back with his front leg on my side. I coulnd't believe the noise. It only went in 3-4 inches. I did see that deer again later in the fall!

It happens, the fact that it bothers you so much shows that you ARE ethical about your shot placement and bowhunting.

Good luck!
 
last year hogie shot a deer in the same spot. we pushed that deer for hours until he was about bled out. but we were fortunate to have some snow cover to make tracking a little easier. most times it's better to leave them for a while before looking as we all know. but last year i found out there are times to get on em and stay on em
 
Same thing happened to me last week with a doe.Hit her right behing shoulder where I should have and only about 4" of arrow was sticking out of her.I tracked her for almost half a mile with good blood and she hit an open cornfield and then nothing.....sucks......
 
Top Bottom