Buck Hollow Sporting Goods - click or touch to visit their website Midwest Habitat Company

Same Buck? Will he break 170s?

TheMadCatter

TheMadCatter

Well-Known Member
I just think it might be him, I know he doesn't have the antler out of his head but he just sticks out more than any other bucks. I think he's low-mid 160s because he has little to no mass. I guess him at 154" just now.

12135-371342_956046.jpg


12135-wow.jpg
 
Last edited:
Hard to say if it's the same deer (assuming your talking about the 10?)

He is much better than 154" :way:

I was very conservative on measurements and I've got him low to mid 60's.

We'll see what he looks like hard horn, but he's got better mass than you think. Hope you crack him :way:
 
Not the same buck! g4s on the new deer are way smaller. frame is alot smaller also. i would say the new buck is a 140ish buck and the big 10 is in the 160s.
 
I disagree fellas......... His right brow is a touch shorter in both years and his left G3 has the same long curvature in both years as well...........

What would make you think that he couldnt add tine length to his G4's from one year to the next?

I think its the same buck and i bet he green grosses somewhere in the upper 50's typical
 
phensway said:
I disagree fellas......... His right brow is a touch shorter in both years and his left G3 has the same long curvature in both years as well...........

What would make you think that he couldnt add tine length to his G4's from one year to the next?

I think its the same buck and i bet he green grosses somewhere in the upper 50's typical
Click to expand...

I agree.....the end of his right main beam also has the same little bend both years. Looks like he added about 20 inches or so.
 
So hard to say if it is the same buck. I guess I would lean towards it being the same buck. The G3's are real similar from last year. I can barely make out the G4's from last years buck...you guys must have unbelievable vision.

I was fairly conservative on some of the measurements and got him at 163. Dandy 10 Josh
 
i also would say its the same buck. even though he doesn't have huge bases, he carries his mass very well and i got him right at 160.
that non typical is pretty cool too. good luck with either of those guys TH!
 
phensway said:
I disagree fellas......... His right brow is a touch shorter in both years and his left G3 has the same long curvature in both years as well...........

What would make you think that he couldnt add tine length to his G4's from one year to the next?

I think its the same buck and i bet he green grosses somewhere in the upper 50's typical
Click to expand...

I just noticed that the dates are different by a year. My bad. With that and looking closer, I agree that its the same buck. Good luck, TH!
 
Defiantly the same deer. Would guess that it scores mid to low 160's. Not a whole lot of mass but really tall and a great looking deer! Good Luck with him!
 
Same buck. 164. If he had average brows he'd be even that much better, but that's just being critical. He's a beautiful deer. Hope you kill him!
 
  • Deleted by N/A
Show…
You must log in or register to reply here.
Top Bottom