Same buck?

[JNRBRONC]

What do you think?

 

[nannyslayer]

Tough to tell, maybe???? I know it is only August in the first pic, but he doesn't have that little start of a G 4 in the velvet pic, but he could have grown it before he shed velvet.

 

[Shredder]

I vote for no.....left side is similar, right is pretty different

 

[DWilk]

The beam on the right side looks different past the G3 how it curves... I don't think it is the same deer... but hey ya got 2 good bucks if they arent

 

[darkhollow1]

I say definately not the same buck. The buck in the first picture has a real curl to his main bean and the one in the second does not.

 

[Windwalker]

no....... both nice ones !

 

[Bowhunter500]

Nope.. def. 2 diff. deer! Great pics tho!

 

[TimberPig]

I'd vote no also. Couple nice ones though!

 

[Kansasdeerslayer]

If you look close, the first one's right side brow tine looks quite a bit longer too. Maybe, maybe not.

 

[Kansasdeerslayer]

After further review, I may not have a clue what I'm talking about.

 

[OHshedder]

At first, I thought definitely no. The longer I stare at it, I think maybe it is. I think the beam curl could be a function of the angle of the shot........so I guess my answer is....I dunno.........

 

[THA4]

i think i may be......but it is very hard to tell for sure
the G-2's and 3's look the same,
i cant see the brows very well which i think may be a deciding factor.....
the small nub on the right beam that didnt quite make it to a G-4 would be covered by the velvet,
so i say the evidence is near inconclusive, but id venture to say yes it is the same deer......

 

[jesseb405]

you should shoot it then present the pictures to it and see what he has to say for himself!

 

[bearpaw1160]

I think so.

 

[DOR]

Negative ghost rider.

 

[Musky Hunter]

I say no

 

[mzldr4life]

I agree on the curve on the right antler, i would say no.

 

[nacho2770]

It is hard to tell with two different camera views, but I would say this is the same buck.