Same Deer?

[jjohnson]

Pretty hard to tell but looks like it could be the same buck. Scrape was within 20yds of the mineral lick last year. Looks like he's still got some good growth left.

Last year November Scrape Video


This Mornings Mineral Lick Pics

 

[THA4]

I'd say same deer

 

[JakeWym]

Looks like the same guy to me...only bigger :way:

 

[Earl E. November]

I say different (Maybe) Left side G4 is now common base with the G3.. Last year it was typical.
Regardless,, Nice deer for sure.

 

[Thinkin Rut]

I'd say probably not because of his G3 and 4 on his left side.

 

[jjohnson]

I still think it's him. I've had deer change way more than what he did in a year. Pretty much impossible to be sure though. I wish every deer had a different marking or a notched ear or something. haha Would make it easier to identify them...

 

[180class]

different deer

 

[Hoyt-R-Nothin]

I would say diff.

 

[SaskGuy]

I also think different deer. It's always hard to tell when they don't stay pretty much the same or have something that makes them easy to i.d like certain features, whether antler wise or cape wise.

 

[Earl E. November]

Deer will add junk as time marches on but basic typical frame seldom changes unless it is to add points..
Shoot him and then do a DNA test..:drink2: