I've had a few of those the past couple of years, but not sure I got pics of the bucks after they shed velvet to confirm if the tine stayed on. I did find a cool shed a couple years ago that had a crooked tine. Started going up like normal, turned 90 degrees for a 1/2", then 90 degrees back up. Found a shed this past spring that resembled it quite a bit, except no crooked tine, so if it was him, I'm guessing he damaged it the previous year. Unfortunately, I may have found the buck laying dead about 30 yards from the shed antler from this spring.