Here’s my 2 cents on tree species…. Pick about “80%” the deer are going to mess with minimally. the 20% they do mess with…. tube them!! Or protect with some method…. PERIOD
heres examples of species (depends on soil) i
would plant so it actually creates a "forest". some of these u can rule out for preference, soil, not your goals. these are ones that will need less protection or possibly none if u plant
enough…. & IMO- u absolutely dont need all trees that "deer love" or produce deer food. most wont. but u want a "forest" - hence my list…. in no particular order….
ash
box elder
maple
Hybrid willow & hybrid poplar
Thornless locust if u could find em.
Mulberry
Sycamore
Nannyberry
Wild plum
Cedar sporadically mixed in.
Hackberry
Osage orange/hedge
Shagbark hickory
Ninebark
Serviceberry
Kentucky coffee
Elm
Protect - tube &/or cage…. Id have at a minimum a handful of these:
Swamp white oak
Any oaks lacking on your land (red, white, burr, etc).
Chinkapin oak
Pin oak
Persimmon
Chestnut (yes, I’d add these & if they won’t approve - I’d add on side). Chinese or 15/16th.
2-4 varieties of crabapple (can add any pear or apple seedlings & tube them)
If u can protect: hazelnut, dogwoods & shrubs deer hit hard……
I’d also get every shrub the iowa dnr offers…. Some get hammered by deer, some don’t. Get all of them IMO. Here’s one example of how I’d handle shrubs…. I’d get every type…. I’d put them at one end of the planting & either make a cheap high fence or double layer TALL electric fence around the shrubs. Could use this technique for all of the plantings deer destroy too. An example might be putting 2-10 of the acres into all the shrubs & trees deer hammer- lumping into one area and keeping deer out of THAT portion. Million ways to do this though.
Get MOST from iowa tree nursery. Find some wholesalers to get rest. Order way in advance. LINK:
No right or wrong here. Tweak your list as needed. I personally like 80% lower maintenance trees & 20% “deer trees” that need to be protected big time.
Good luck!