About 5 of us are fiends and have neighboring farms in Van Buren County. It seems we lost many of our mature bucks. Several were our best bucks. Overall numbers seem down considerably, also.
I am right next to Van Buren in Davis and our neighborhood sounds just like yours. This was a VERY thin fall for hunting in our area, we only shot one buck. Normally, we would shoot 1 or 2 bucks and 6-10 does off of our place. All other neighbors had similar tales this year and probably 75%+ of "our" bucks disappeared off camera this fall. We all anticipate a "fruitful" shed, or shall I say deadhead, season.
But...some positivity...I was very curious how long the "rebuild process" might take in our area. One year, five years, who knows??? We had info that indicated that there was at least a several square mile area around us that was similarly impacted, so it wasn't as if surplus bucks were going to be able to jog across the road to us and fill us back up.
Since about late Nov up until now though, all of our neighbors and us have been "picking up" bucks, as evidenced by a good amount of pics on trail cams. OK, alrighty then, this is great news. Where there was only a limited number of bucks, and most of them were young pencil racks, in Oct through mid Nov...now there are "some", not the usual amount yet, but some...and some are older age class. I would LOVE to know how far these creatures had to travel to get to us...but at least we have some out there now, where there were very, very few just 6-8 weeks ago.
I suspect that we picked some up via rut related travels in mid-to-late Nov and then some more related to gun hunting pressure elsewhere, but I really don't know. I am pretty confident though that they didn't just come from neighboring properties though. A good number of what we are seeing now are "new" bucks, ones that none of us recognize. We do have excellent habitat in our neighborhood and pretty good food, albeit drought limited once again, so maybe we are getting more than our "share" since our places are better habitats???
But, no matter where these beasts are coming from it is more apparent this year than ever...if you build it, they will come.