I believe the early muzzleloader is fine as it is. We have never had a problem getting tags for it. We have seen deer in the past two seasons that we have hunted it. I like to do it early because of a few reasons. Early muzzle can fall in that time where possibly pre rut could start, as it just missed it this year in my area. Two, some of the crops such as beans are still in and deer will feed in these areas. and third if i went late season with the amount of pressure that are on the deer in my area from shotgun hunters can sometimes be impossible to either gain permission to hunt the places the deer are now hiding at since nobody hunts that land that the deer have found their way to or the deer are way to spooky to hunt for the party hunting.