letemgrow
PMA Member
That can squeeze a lot of farmers since cash rent rates don't follow the commodity price trends.
Most landowners aren't going to start taking less when the commodities halve in price.....
Land prices / insane!!!
- Thread starter Wi transplant
- Start date
-
- Tags
- None
That can squeeze a lot of farmers since cash rent rates don't follow the commodity price trends.
Most landowners aren't going to start taking less when the commodities halve in price.....
Snail3496
Active Member
I am in way no way questioning Bill Winke, he's one of the greats, but I have been continually surprised at how openly intrusive he is. He walks through a good portion of his wide open main bottom field to hunt it over and over and I always wonder how in the world he gets out at night without blowing the place out. Same with zig zagging up the hills on his quad with dogs all Sept/Oct checking chips every few days. Maybe I'm just way too conservative and over think, but it seems like it could make a difference.
It's fun watching a good old bowhunter like him hunt for all the right reasons and not try to be flashy, especially nowadays. You sure don't see any instagram flatbillers spending the night at the bottom of their tree!
Last edited:
I know his filming crew now, or some of them I should say (they moved here from Wisconsin) and basically, they condition the deer to tolerate them. I will say the deer at my home place tolerate a whole lot more than my farm in Allamakee that I am never on. So I do understand that piece of the puzzle.
That being said, it amazes me on how much ground he found to buy in that area, I have heard stories, but will absolutely not reshare those.
daniel93077
Active Member
Fully agree…key word there is “typically”…but it’s definitely not always. The differences in degree of rise and fall can really be a game changer to from a uncorrelated/diversifier standpoint.
The real risks are the things we can’t see. Maybe there won’t be another Savings and Loan crisis but it definitely doesn’t mean a 30% drop in land price will never again be in our future. I have to think that it definitely will be at some point…whether that’s in our lifetime…who knows.
Last edited:
Windlooker
Well-Known Member
I’ll take that bet. You’ll never see 4k again. This isn’t the 1980 commodities crash. No comparison. Rec ground wasn’t a thing then. During the 08 crash, caused by Bill Clinton’s everyone should own a house even though they can’t afford it program that he began in 1995, rec ground held steady. A substantial decline is wishful thinking.
daniel93077
Active Member
We may not see $4K again but we could see a crash of that magnitude. Say rec land prices are averaging $10K, it’s possible it could go back to $7K. The reason it’s so common for us to think that can’t happen is because we can’t see or know what would cause it to do that today. True risks aren’t the things we know are likely to happen. I don’t know that such a thing will happen in my lifetime so I’d never take that bet.. and I wouldn’t let that concern stop me from buying land if I had capacity to take that risk.
Slick
Well-Known Member
Windlooker would you like to make a friendly wager of $100 that in the next 2 years i will be able to show proof of a property that sells for less than 4k per acre in the bottom tier of Iowa?
Attachments
Hardwood11
It is going to be a good fall!
When Bill Winke first sold his farm, his timing was terrible and the run up literally took place after he sold.
It was too cheap. Just my opinion, but big farms like that should command a premium !
It was too cheap. Just my opinion, but big farms like that should command a premium !
There will always be extreme outliers. Someone that is on their way out that gives someone a killer deal out of good will, someone that gets bamboozled, someone with an extreme urgent need to sell immediately, etc. I know of a KILLER farm that sold for under 4k just a few months ago. Old guy liked the dudes that leased it and gave them a great deal. All of the above happen.
A far better metric is looking at average sale prices per acre of similar property.
Extreme outliers (high or low) don't really prove anything
I'd say big farms sell for less per acre. Just an incredibly small buyer pool.
Hardwood11
It is going to be a good fall!
You better check with Skip on that . I’d say it depends on several factors, but if it’s good, it will sell high !
daniel93077
Active Member
Yeah- There’s a few land agents and attorney’s I see that seem to get really great deals semi-frequently then turn around and sell them. Seems questionable from an ethical standpoint to me. I hope they know many of us know who they are too. I definitely wouldn’t be doing business with them.
eh I can think of a half dozen farms roughly that size that have sold off market within 20 miles of his new place in the last 3 or 4 years. I am surprised he hasn't been able to turn up much in that neighborhood though. There was an absolute bomber of a typical shot just down the river last fall.
I curious to see who bought this. Just down the road.
jflournoy
Active Member
jflournoy
Active Member
Definitely true in the vast majority of cases. Though occasionally if it's a super special farm or is an unusually large contiguous landholding for the area, sometimes that will cause it to actually sell for a premium. But best to figure in most cases that a smaller pool of legit buyers = buyer has more leverage than seller on sales price.
They certainly can, but more often than not they will be below average market value for that area on a per acre basis. Anecdotally, big Warren co farm ~ 800 acres just sold for mid 5's. You arn't buying anything in Warren under 200 acres for less than mid 6's (rare exceptions)
Thinkin Rut
PMA Member
I wonder as time goes on and larger REC pieces get split up, if the larger tracts will then become more valuable vs smaller.
Windlooker
Well-Known Member
I think larger tracts, 600ac plus, were established years ago when timber was considered garbage land. Many hunters want to own as much as possible but money limitations today with the crazy prices break up the tracts. Guys with the resources to own a bunch of acres are few. Add in that most serious hunters are solitary and do not want partners to lessen cost exacerbates the land break up. Most of the time partners are a bad idea. At some point, for some reason, a guy wants out. The battle begins.
Thinkin Rut
PMA Member
I'm thinking the real risks are the ones we choose not to see or look at. People today are so orgasmic over land, they don't take into account all the what ifs.