Today I had one of the most fun hunts I have ever had, without killing anything. I have tried rattling for several years and have never once had anything come in. I moved a stand to a part of the property I hunt that I had never been to before. Put the stand up and sat down at about 11:30. At 10 til Noon I decided I would try and rattle. I rattled for about 15 seconds or so, put them down, and within 30 seconds there was movement in the brush. It was a nice 10 pointer! He came in to 15 yards broadside just as planned, but wasn't quite big enough. He was missing his G2 on the right side or I may have let him have it.
He wandered off, and about an hour later I rattled again. Sure enough, within 2-3 minutes, a 100" 8 pointer shows up out of no where! Stops perfectly in my shooting lane, but again, I let him walk. Anyways, I rattle 6 times today, and had 4 different bucks come in! The last one was a fork horn that actually caught me red handed with the horns still in my hands!
Anyway, saw a total of 6 bucks and only 1 doe. Sat from 11:30 til dark in Winneshiek county. Saw most of the deer midday, and no action at dusk.