I like mucks...alot! They are the only rubber boots I've ever owned that didn't have a hole torn in them within the first year. However, two potential negatives I see would be 1) If you have arch problems in your feet, you'd probably want something with a little more support in that area. And 2) It really takes 2 pair of mucks to cover most of the season...but that's probably true with other brands of boots as well. Both pair of mucks I have are going on 8-9 years, but are now due to be replaced. A little spendy, but I'm going right back with the same thing...Fieldblazer and Woody Max.