Same Buck?

[SEIowaDeerslayer]

Def. same deer.

 

[JBAGS]

Id say same deer....and also side with dedgeez that he has packed
on some good size. Hope u can update us with hard horn pics

 

[turtlshell]

I'm back and forth, but leaning towards the 2011 buck being an older "updated" version of your old pal Top-Hat. He's a smoker, go get him!:way:

 

[Blaster]

I would say yes.

 

[KSQ2]

Same deer imo...

 

[scottonbuck]

Different deer look at the white ring around the muzzle/nose of the first and compare that to the second. The first has a perfect white ring around his nose. Very similar but different, maybe Top Hats Daddy?

 

[gansomn]

I say negative. The nose is the give away here boys. Racks change... color not so much. Who cares he is a awesome deer.

 

[hornhntr]

I would say no to same deer yes to same genetics.