I'd say he's an older buck, score wise he won't score well but I guess the trophy is in the eye of the beholder. If your happy with him, shoot him don't let others dictate you from shooting him or not. I also think age really doest matter if you think he's a trophy and you want him take him. Can't get big if you don't let them reach maturity but what is maturity, each deers potential is different, some deer have it some don't. If you have a wall full of 150's you could pry reason on why you'd want a bigger one, if your a meat hunter, well antlers don't taste, etc etc etc. Good luck with your decision hopefully he presents you a shot and your able to harvest him :way::way: