The neighbor thing is dependent, right. If one can own large chunks, 600 plus acres, neighbors matter but not really. With that amount of land the owner can control the deer herd to a point. Smaller land owners, which is most, wound never buy if based on the neighbors. In reality it takes several years to truly know who the neighbors are.
The owners who surround my place are local farmers who could care less about my herd structure, lol. That said I get along with them, we kill some nice deer, and I love my place. My place consists of 2/3 timber and 1/3 crp/crop with running water traversing the property. Running water, not cattle ponds, is a must IMO.