Would you rather..

[SaskGuy]

I don't think it's a matter of neighbors being irresponsible. I think it's that there is a lot of competition for the resource. I've spoke with many of the hunters in my neighborhood and they all seem to be great people, even if they shoot 3 yr olds!

I agree. Just because I hope bucks reach 5 yrs plus does not mean I expect everyone to think the same.

 

[ironwood]

Depends on the quality of the neighborhood. I will pick a superior quality neighborhood with great genetics and neighbors before anything else.

That being said in your scenario managed.

Totally the difference

 

[VictoryOutdoor]

I'd have to say "Managed" and as others have said neighborhood is key! Unless you are buying really big but if your under 500 acres, neighborhood would play a big role for me!