Buck Hollow Sporting Goods - click or touch to visit their website Midwest Habitat Company

Horses??

Crimson Arrows

Well-Known Member
I was wondering if anybody on here can give me some advice on a problem I am having. My neighbor on my farm down south has been letting his horses loose for awhile. We are not on good terms, I have tried and tried to be the better person through the years but he has done everything from stealing a cuddeback to using salt blocks over stands, cutting down trees ON MY SIDE of the fence to shoot into my field etc. I was warned when I bought the property by the previous owner about their poaching, and in fact they are currently being looked at for two cases that I had no clue about. I had no idea somebody could be so inconsiderate.

I eventually bought his timber and acres when he wanted to sell 2 years ago and thought I was rid of the problem. Well, he has let his 3 horses run free of late and i just paid alot of $$ to have alfalfa planted and they are running back and forth through the new seedlings daily. I called him and left very polite messages but he won't return the calls. We finally had the sheriff deputy stop to talk to him and they penned them immediately but then they were out again the next day. They have droppings all through my food plots, trails, etc. I just don't know what to do legally or if they can do that legally then maybe I have no options. Any advice is appreciated as I was hoping somebody may have had a similar problem and how they dealt with it???
 
Found this in the code of Iowa.


Senate File 219
Partial Bill History

* Bill Introduced: S.J. 401
* Committee Report Issued: S.J. 390 H.J. 917
* Passed House: H.J. 1200
* Passed Senate: S.J. 476
* Signed by Governor: S.J. 1345
* Complete Bill History

Bill Text

PAG LIN
1 1 SENATE FILE 219
1 2
1 3 <span style="color: #FF0000">AN ACT</span>
1 4 <span style="color: #FF0000">RELATING TO TRESPASSING OR STRAY LIVESTOCK AND PROVIDING</span>
1 5 <span style="color: #FF0000">REMEDIES AND AN EFFECTIVE DATE.</span>
1 6
1 7 BE IT ENACTED BY THE GENERAL ASSEMBLY OF THE STATE OF IOWA:
1 8
1 9 Section 1. NEW SECTION. 169C.1 DEFINITIONS.
1 10 As used in this chapter, unless the context otherwise
1 11 requires:
1 12 1. "Aggrieved party" means a landowner or a local
1 13 authority.
1 14 2. "Landowner" means a person who holds an interest in
1 15 land, including a titleholder or tenant.
1 16 3. "Livestock" means an animal belonging to the bovine,
1 17 caprine, equine, ovine, or porcine species; ostriches, rheas,
1 18 or emus; farm deer as defined in section 481A.1; or poultry.
1 19 4. "Livestock care provider" means a person designated by
1 20 a local authority to provide care to livestock which is
1 21 distrained by a local authority.
1 22 5. "Livestock owner" means the person who holds title to
1 23 livestock or who is primarily responsible for the care and
1 24 feeding of the livestock as provided by the titleholder.
1 25 6. "Local authority" means a city as defined in section
1 26 362.2 or a county as provided in chapter 331.
1 27 7. "Maintenance" means the provision of shelter, food,
1 28 water, or a nutritional formulation as required pursuant to
1 29 chapter 717.
1 30 Sec. 2. NEW SECTION. 169C.2 CUSTODY AND MAINTENANCE.
1 31 A landowner may take custody of livestock if the livestock
1 32 trespasses upon the landowner's land or strays from the
1 33 livestock owner's control on a public road which adjoins the
1 34 landowner's land. A local authority may take custody of the
1 35 livestock as provided by the local authority. The landowner
2 1 shall not transfer custody of the livestock to a person other
2 2 than the livestock owner or a local authority, unless the
2 3 livestock owner approves of the transfer. A local authority
2 4 shall not transfer custody of the livestock to a person other
2 5 than the livestock owner or a livestock care provider.
2 6 Sec. 3. NEW SECTION. 169C.3 NOTICE TO LIVESTOCK OWNER.
2 7 1. a. If livestock trespasses upon a landowner's land or
2 8 the landowner takes custody of the livestock, the landowner
2 9 shall deliver notice of the trespass or custody to the
2 10 livestock owner within forty-eight hours following discovery
2 11 of the trespass or taking custody of livestock which has not
2 12 trespassed. If a local authority takes custody of the
2 13 livestock, the local authority shall deliver notice of the
2 14 custody to the livestock owner within forty-eight hours after
2 15 taking custody of the livestock. The forty-eight-hour period
2 16 shall exclude any time that falls on a Sunday or a holiday
2 17 recognized by the state or the United States. The notice
2 18 shall be made in writing and delivered by certified mail or
2 19 personal service to the last known mailing address of the
2 20 livestock owner.
2 21 b. If the aggrieved party does not know the name and
2 22 address of the livestock owner, the aggrieved party shall make
2 23 reasonable efforts to determine the identity of the livestock
2 24 owner. The reasonable efforts shall include obtaining the
2 25 name and address of the owner of the brand appearing on the
2 26 livestock from the department of agriculture and land
2 27 stewardship under chapter 169A. If the name and address of
2 28 the livestock owner cannot be determined, the aggrieved party
2 29 shall publish the notice as soon as possible at least once
2 30 each week for two consecutive weeks in a newspaper having
2 31 general circulation in the county where the livestock is
2 32 located.
2 33 2. A notice required under this section shall at least
2 34 provide all of the following:
2 35 a. The name and address of the landowner or local
3 1 authority.
3 2 b. A description of the livestock and where it trespassed
3 3 or strayed.
3 4 c. An estimate of the amount of the livestock owner's
3 5 liability.
3 6 Sec. 4. NEW SECTION. 169C.4 LIABILITY.
3 7 1. A livestock owner shall be liable to the following
3 8 persons:
3 9 a. To a landowner for damages caused by the livestock
3 10 owner's livestock which have trespassed on the landowner's
3 11 land, including but not limited to property damage and costs
3 12 incurred by a landowner's custody of the livestock including
3 13 maintenance costs. A livestock owner's liability is not
3 14 affected by the failure of a landowner to take custody of the
3 15 livestock. A livestock owner shall not be liable for damages
3 16 incurred by the landowner if the livestock trespassed through
3 17 a fence that was not maintained by the landowner as required
3 18 pursuant to chapter 359A.
3 19 b. To a landowner who takes custody of livestock on a
3 20 public road as provided in section 169C.3 for costs incurred
3 21 by the landowner in taking custody of the livestock, including
3 22 maintenance costs.
3 23 c. To a local authority which takes custody of livestock
3 24 for costs incurred by the local authority in taking custody of
3 25 the livestock, including maintenance costs.
3 26 2. An aggrieved party who fails to provide timely notice
3 27 of a livestock's trespass or custody as required by section
3 28 169C.3 shall not be entitled to compensation for damages for
3 29 the period of time during which the aggrieved party fails to
3 30 provide timely notice.
3 31 3. An aggrieved party is not liable for an injury or death
3 32 suffered by the livestock in the landowner's custody, unless
3 33 the landowner caused the injury or death. The landowner is
3 34 not liable for livestock that strays from the landowner's
3 35 land. An aggrieved party is not liable for livestock that
4 1 strays from the control of the aggrieved party.
4 2 Sec. 5. NEW SECTION. 169C.5 SATISFACTION FOR DAMAGES.
4 3 1. a. After receiving notice by an aggrieved party as
4 4 required by section 169C.3, the livestock owner shall pay all
4 5 damages to the aggrieved party for which the livestock owner
4 6 is liable.
4 7 b. The aggrieved party or the livestock owner may bring a
4 8 civil action in order to determine the livestock owner's
4 9 liability and the amount of any claim for damages. The
4 10 aggrieved party or livestock owner must bring the action
4 11 within thirty days following receipt or publication of the
4 12 notice as required by section 169C.3. The court may join all
4 13 other claims arising out of the same facts that are alleged in
4 14 the claim for damages. The civil action may be heard by a
4 15 district judge or a district associate judge. The civil
4 16 action may be heard by the district court sitting in small
4 17 claims as provided in chapter 631.
4 18 c. If the livestock is in the custody of an aggrieved
4 19 party or livestock care provider, a rebuttable presumption
4 20 arises that the livestock has trespassed or strayed from the
4 21 control of the livestock owner. The rebuttable presumption
4 22 shall not apply if a criminal charge has been filed involving
4 23 the removal or transfer of the livestock. The burden of proof
4 24 regarding all other matters of dispute shall be on the
4 25 aggrieved party.
4 26 d. The failure of an aggrieved party to provide notice as
4 27 required by section 169C.3 shall not bar the aggrieved party
4 28 from being awarded a judgment, if the court determines that
4 29 the livestock owner had actual knowledge that the livestock
4 30 had trespassed or strayed and the name and address of the
4 31 aggrieved party.
4 32 2. If a civil action is brought by the livestock owner or
4 33 aggrieved party, the matter shall be heard by a court on an
4 34 expedited basis. The aggrieved party shall provide for the
4 35 transfer of the livestock to the livestock owner, if the
5 1 livestock owner posts a bond or other security with the court
5 2 in the amount of the aggrieved party's claim. If a bond or
5 3 security is not posted, the aggrieved party or livestock care
5 4 provider shall keep custody of and provide maintenance to the
5 5 livestock. However, the livestock owner shall post the bond
5 6 or other security if the matter is set for hearing more than
5 7 thirty days from the date that the petition bringing the civil
5 8 action is filed. The court shall order the immediate
5 9 disposition of the livestock as provided in chapter 717, if
5 10 the livestock is permanently distressed by disease or injury
5 11 to a degree that would result in severe or prolonged
5 12 suffering.
5 13 3. If a civil action is not timely brought as provided in
5 14 this section, title to the livestock shall transfer to the
5 15 aggrieved party thirty days following receipt of the notice by
5 16 the livestock owner or the first date of the notice's
5 17 publication as required pursuant to section 169C.3, if the
5 18 parties fail to agree to the amount, terms, or conditions of
5 19 payment or if the identity of the livestock owner cannot be
5 20 determined. Title to the livestock shall transfer subject to
5 21 any applicable security interests or liens.
5 22 4. A landowner is liable to the livestock owner for twice
5 23 the fair market value of livestock that the landowner
5 24 transfers to a person other than a local authority in
5 25 violation of section 169C.2.
5 26 5. If the aggrieved party is a local authority, the local
5 27 authority shall reimburse the landowner for the landowner's
5 28 damages from proceeds received from the sale of the livestock,
5 29 after satisfying any superior security interests or liens.
5 30 Sec. 6. EFFECTIVE DATE. This Act, being deemed of
5 31 immediate importance, takes effect upon enactment.
5 32
5 33
5 34
5 35 MARY E. KRAMER
6 1 President of the Senate
6 2
6 3
6 4
6 5 RON J. CORBETT
6 6 Speaker of the House
6 7
6 8 I hereby certify that this bill originated in the Senate and
6 9 is known as Senate File 219, Seventy-seventh General Assembly.
6 10
6 11
6 12
6 13 MARY PAT GUNDERSON
6 14 Secretary of the Senate
6 15 Approved , 1997
6 16
6 17
6 18
6 19 TERRY E. BRANSTAD
6 20 Governor
 
<div class="ubbcode-block"><div class="ubbcode-header">Quote:</div><div class="ubbcode-body">A livestock owner shall not be liable for damages
3 16 incurred by the landowner if the livestock trespassed through
3 17 a fence that was not maintained by the landowner as required
3 18 pursuant to chapter 359A.
</div></div>

That's an important factor right there...are they getting in through a fence (or lack of it) that your responsible for?

I know it's a pain but just another reason to keep good line fences and road fence.

Dang horses...can't even sell em for horse burger anymore...
/forum/images/%%GRAEMLIN_URL%%/wink.gif
 
Down at the bottom it says that if you file the correct papers, after 30 days (I know, long time to mess with horses) you become the owner of the livestock, to do with what you wish.

If nothing else, you can sell them at auction and make some damage money back.
 
I saw that but problem is he will pen them back up about 1 hour before I get home and releases them mid morning. So they aren't out 24/7 and therefore not close to 30 days.
 
i think a 100 gr. muzzy might do the trick.... /forum/images/%%GRAEMLIN_URL%%/grin.gif


get a hold of your local CO, they will help for sure!
 
Get on your 4 wheeler and chance those damn horses into the next county!!!!

See if he keeps them penned up then...
 
We have tried but they always come home. Just talked to the deputy and he is not a fan of this guy but gave me some good advice on the township trustees and how to handle it. What goes around comes around and they are MORE than willing to help out. Still, sad deal anybody has to deal with this kind of immature stuff.
 
<div class="ubbcode-block"><div class="ubbcode-header">Originally Posted By: THA4</div><div class="ubbcode-body">

get a hold of your local CO, they will help for sure! </div></div>

Actually, the SO is probably be the best route. Like Dbltree pointed out and you acknowledged make sure the fences are up to par, and hopefully that will take care of the problem. The horse owner sounds like a class act - knowingly letting his horses out on others property.
 
<div class="ubbcode-block"><div class="ubbcode-header">Originally Posted By: nacho</div><div class="ubbcode-body">Get on your 4 wheeler and chance those damn horses into the next county!!!!

See if he keeps them penned up then... </div></div>

I had the same problem with horses and cattle on my property. They knocked over my 3-D targets and trampled all over my new yard seeding. Chasing with 4-wheeler would send them running but they always came back. I learned that 7-shot in a 20 ga. from about 40 yds puts just enough lead in their a$$ to make them want to stay away! /forum/images/%%GRAEMLIN_URL%%/blush.gif
 
That will definetely work for sure. /forum/images/%%GRAEMLIN_URL%%/grin.gif

A good peppering will change their minds for sure...




When I said chase them with the 4 wheeler, I meant get some buddies together and chance those horses like 20 miles down the road...

That ought to take them awhile to find their way home..
 
Chase......


thats how you spell it Josh...
/forum/images/%%GRAEMLIN_URL%%/grin.gif
 
<div class="ubbcode-block"><div class="ubbcode-header">Originally Posted By: THA4</div><div class="ubbcode-body">Chase......


thats how you spell it Josh...
/forum/images/%%GRAEMLIN_URL%%/grin.gif </div></div>

nutkick.gif
 
Top Bottom