Public worse than outfitters IMO. Completely unrestricted chaos going on. Outfitters, you got guys who "paid for a deer" and better get one and your young good gen bucks get slayed even with restrictions. Most outfitters run way too many guys through. Some are good but rare.
Personally, I wouldn't wanna be any closer than a mile from either scenario. I'd avoid Public, outfitted areas, Missouri border & a few other scenarios like the plague. Honestly, my best neighbor would be someone I liked and trusted that managed how I did that was an out of stater with a large tract.... Low pressure & you know every year there isn't gonna have 8 bucks whacked out of it. Or a guy that hunts alone or with 1-2 people but also owns farms in other areas (low pressure as well). I'd strongly look for areas with larger land owners. makes for so many less hunters than areas filled with 40's, 80's, 160's. Even if they are good managers, really hard to have top notch ground with that many groups and landowners.