Thomas, that's a tough situation a lot of us face every year. If he's not what you want this year, then let him walk and pray he makes it through again...like they said above, he did it last year.
Also, with last years November pic I'd say 3.5 in 2010...4.5 this year. I've never seen a 2.5'r with that big of a body like the November 2010 pic.
BTW - if you have pics of him in 2012, he's going to make you chit-yourself:way: because he will be a true HAWG